Textiles
Sheets
All Sheets
French Linen
Comforters
Duvets
Blankets
Kantha Quilts
Pillows
All Pillows
Throw Pillow
Floor Pillow
Bed Pillow
Babies+Kids
All Babies & Kids
Curious Little Fingers Collection
Storybook Collection
Sweet Tooth Collection
Kids Quilts+Blankets
Swaddles
Crib Sheets
Bathroom Textiles
Kitchen Textiles
Apothecary & Redolence
All Apothecary & Redolence
Beauty
Shampoo & Conditioner
Soap
Lotions & Butters
Tinte Vintage Cosmetics
Bath Salts, Bombs & Teas
Bath Salts, Bombs, & Teas
Bath Bombs
Aromatherapy Jewlery
Soap+Accessories
Air+Linen Sprays
Candles+Reed Diffusers
Brands
Agnes + Cat
Kiss Me in the Garden
Live Beautifully
Spinster Sister
Swanky Sweet Pea
Vintage Lip Licking
Velvet Whiskey Candle Co.
Z&Co.
Rugs
All Rugs
Kids Rugs
Jute Rugs
Fashion Accessories
Handbags & Totes
Coin Purse
Zippered Pouches
Scarves
Home Decor
Nostalgic Candy
All Candy
Around the Globe
Imported Chocolate
Imported Sweets
Savory Snacks
V&C Candy Factory
Chocolate Nummies
Taffy, Caramels & Nougat
Licorice
Brittle & Peanuts
Gummy Nummies
Gum
Novelty Candy
Lollipops, Hard Candy & Everything Else
Vintage Sodas
All Vintage Sodas
Vintage Soda Flavors
Vintage Soda Brands
Novelty Soda
Vintage Toys
Stocking Stuffers
Unique Gifts
Violets & Cream - Ice Cream Shoppe
Skip to content
Submit
Close search
HOME
SHOP
Fragrances & Accessories
Rugs
Duvets
Bedding Essentials
Bathroom Textiles
Kids
Blankets
Comforters
Sheets
ABOUT US
LATEST NEWS
CONTACT US
Submit
Search
Log in
Cart
HOME
SHOP
SHOP Menu
SHOP
Fragrances & Accessories
Rugs
Duvets
Bedding Essentials
Bathroom Textiles
Kids
Blankets
Comforters
Sheets
ABOUT US
LATEST NEWS
CONTACT US
Collection:
Peanut Butter
10 products
Sort
Sort
Featured
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Abba Zaba Chewy Taffy - Peanut Butter Center
Abba Zaba Chewy Taffy - Peanut Butter Center
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$2.00
Sale
Boyer Butterscotch Smoothie Cup
Boyer Butterscotch Smoothie Cup
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Sale
Boyer Jimmie Stix - Milk Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Pretzel
Boyer Jimmie Stix - Milk Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Pretzel
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Sale
Old Fashioned - Peanut Butter Soda
Old Fashioned - Peanut Butter Soda
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Sale
Boyer - Clark Cups
Boyer - Clark Cups
Regular price
$1.75
Sale price
$1.75
Sale
Blue Moose - Belgian Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Blue Moose - Belgian Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$5.00
Sale
C3 Fall Collection Chocolate Gift Box
C3 Fall Collection Chocolate Gift Box
Regular price
$11.00
Sale price
$11.00
Sale
Hershey's - 5th Avenue
Hershey's - 5th Avenue
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$2.00
Sale
Long Grove - Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Melts
Long Grove - Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Melts
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$11.75
Sale
Hammonds Chocolate Bar - PB&J Milk Chocolate
Hammonds Chocolate Bar - PB&J Milk Chocolate
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$3.75
Sale