Collection: Nostalgic Candy & Soda

All the sweetness we carry, right here. If you are looking for specific items please check out our sweet collections.
403 products
Apothecary - Cream Soda
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Apothecary - Black Cherry
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Apothecary - Root Beer Soda
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Melville - Sizzlin Bacon Lollipop
Regular price
$3.00
Sale price
$3.00
Wack-O-Wax Mustache
Regular price
$1.50
Sale price
$1.50
Wack-O-Wax Lips
Regular price
$1.50
Sale price
$1.50
Wack-O-Wax Fangs
Regular price
$1.50
Sale price
$1.50
C3 Fall Collection Chocolate Gift Box
Regular price
$11.00
Sale price
$11.00
Farmers Popcorn
Regular price
$5.00
Sale price
$5.00
Wicked Apple Brew - Seasonal
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Dr Jekyll Peppe Elixir Soda - Seasonal
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Fort Knox - Extra Large Medallion
Regular price
$3.75
Sale price
$3.75
Tie Dye Cube Pops
Regular price
$0.75
Sale price
$0.75
Zotz Strings - Assorted
Regular price
$1.00
Sale price
$1.00
Jolly Rancher Hard Candy - Assortment
Regular price
$1.75
Sale price
$1.75
Ice Cream Candy Twist-N-Lik
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Jumbo Gummy Bears - Assorted
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$8.00
Melville - Beer Lollipop
Regular price
$3.00
Sale price
$3.00
Hammond’s Chocolate Bar - Birthday Cake
Regular price
$3.75
Sale price
$3.75
Hammond’s - Chocolate Biscuit Bar
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Hammond’s - Pecan & Caramel Piggy Back Turtles
Regular price
$4.00
Sale price
$4.00
Hammond’s Chocolate Bar - PB&J Milk Chocolate
Regular price
$3.75
Sale price
$3.75
Hammond’s - Chocolate Peppermint Caramel Bites
Regular price
$1.25
Sale price
$1.25
Strawberry Crush Soda - w/ Real Cane Sugar
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Annabelle's - Rocky Road - Sea Salt
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Boyer - Dark Chocolate Mallo Cup
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Necco Wafers - Original
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Pop Rocks - Strawberry
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$1.75
Giant Sour Apple Carnival Lollipop
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$2.50
Pickle Ice Freezer Pops
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Abba Zaba Chewy Taffy - Mystery Flavor
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Magic Potion - Color Changing Sour Liquid Candy
Regular price
$2.75
Sale price
$2.75
Charms - Scaredy Cats - Cotton Candy
Regular price
$3.00
Sale price
$3.00
Psychedelic Sours Giant 2 1/4" Jawbreakers
Regular price
$3.50
Sale price
$3.50
Frostie - Green Apple Soda
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Dublin - Ginger Ale
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Annabelle's - Rocky Road - Mint
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Annabelle's - Rocky Road - S'mores
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
Frostop - Root Beer Soda
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Nesbitt's - Peach
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50