Collection: Nostalgic Candy

All the sweetness we carry, right here. If you are looking for specific items please check out our sweet collections.
253 products
Raindrops - Gummy Donut
Regular price
$5.75
Sale price
$5.75
Fort Knox Milk Chocolate Ingots
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
the original - Chimes - Cayenne Lemon
Regular price
$2.75
Sale price
$2.75
the original - Chimes - Meyer Lemon
Regular price
$2.75
Sale price
$2.75
Hammonds Chocolate Bar - Coconut Cream Pie
Regular price
$3.75
Sale price
$3.75
Hammonds Chocolate Bar - Toffee Brittle
Regular price
$3.75
Sale price
$3.75
Hammonds Chocolate Bar - Mint Chocolate Chip
Regular price
$3.75
Sale price
$3.75
UK - Burts Potato Chips - Sweet Chili
Regular price
$5.00
Sale price
$5.00
UK - Burts Potato Chips - Mature Cheddar & Green Onion
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$5.00
UK - Tayto Potato Chips - Wuster Sauce
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
UK - Tayto Potato Chips - Smokey Bacon
Regular price
$2.00
Sale price
$2.00
UK - Hadleigh Maid Coffee Truffle Walnut Whirls
Regular price
$7.50
Sale price
$7.50
UK - Romney's - Kendal Mint Cake
Regular price
$2.75
Sale price
$2.75
Melville - Holiday Lollipop
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$2.75
Long Grove - Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Melts
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$11.75
Madelaine Victorian Toy Village Advent Calendar
Regular price
$14.50
Sale price
$14.50
Madelaine Chocolate Snowflake Ornament
Regular price
$1.25
Sale price
$1.25
Belfine Belgian Chocolate Reindeer Lollipop
Regular price
$3.50
Sale price
$3.50
Belgian Chocolate Peek a Boo Surprise Egg
Regular price
$2.75
Sale price
$2.75
Hammonds - Chocolate Filled Candy Cane
Regular price
$3.50
Sale price
$3.50
Madelaine Ice Cream Cone
Regular price
$1.00
Sale price
$1.00
Madelaine Santa's Workshop Countdown Advent Calendar
Regular price
$13.50
Sale price
$13.50
Madelaine Mini Race Car - Chocolate Gift Set
Regular price
$7.50
Sale price
$7.50
Kimmie Chocolate Rocks - Christmas Edition
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$3.50
Jawbreaker on a Stick
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$3.50
Sour Pickle Balls
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$3.00
Fort Knox - Large Bag Milk Chocolate Gold Coins
Regular price
$2.75
Sale price
$2.75
Mega Bruiser Giant Jawbreaker
Regular price
$10.50
Sale price
$10.50
Cadbury UK - Chocolate Mousse Snowman
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$4.00
Nestle UK - Yorkie
Regular price
$3.00
Sale price
$3.00
Cadbury UK - Fudge
Regular price
$1.50
Sale price
$1.50
Giant Carnival Lollipop
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$2.50
Slush Puppy - Giant Gummy
Regular price
More Coming Soon!
Sale price
$2.75
Smarties
Regular price
$15.00
Sale price
$15.00
Pop Rocks Xtreme - Super Sour Assorted
Regular price
$1.75
Sale price
$1.75
Regal Crown Rolls - Sour Apple
Regular price
$1.75
Sale price
$1.75
Gustafs - Gumbilees Gourmet Wine Gum
Regular price
$3.75
Sale price
$3.75
Blue Moose - Sea Salt Caramel Fudge
Regular price
$5.00
Sale price
$5.00
Melville - Sizzlin Bacon Lollipop
Regular price
$3.00
Sale price
$3.00
Wack-O-Wax Mustache
Regular price
$1.50
Sale price
$1.50